|
Antysemite
|
|
On the Thanks Giving day in Sarasota, Florida, a group of elderly Poles were invited to celebrate the occasion in a hospitable home of a decorated veteran of the Home Army, who during the tragic Warsaw Uprising was ordered to assist a group of Jews who tried to save themselves outside of the ghetto on the Arian side. During an after dinner conversation one of the ladies asked her family friend: “Are you an anti-Semite?” and in return she was asked: “How do you define an anti-Semite?” Then it was recalled that professor of theology and one of the foremost authority on the Bible at the University of Cardinal Wyszyński in Warsaw, Monsegnior Waldemar Chrostowski convincingly defined an anti-Semite as “a person disliked by some Jew.”
“Salon 24,” an independent forum printed a review of Professor Chrostowski’s scholarly volume entitled: “The Church and the Jews in Poland,” in which he faced bravely the reining terror of political correctness in post-Communist Polish society. The author clearly states that Jews are not responsible in 100% for the phenomenon of anti-Semitism. However, professor Chrostowski is accused of anti-Semitism, because he dares to discuss Jews normally, the same way as he discusses non-Jews – a fact which caused him to be condemned by the now reigning “political correctness” and evicted from the participation in “theological discussions” in the Tygodnik Powszechny. This condemnation is answered by the motto of his book: “It is enough not to let oneself be intimidated,” in the present era of “anti-Semitic-phobia.”
Naturally prof Chrostowski condemns the idea very popular in Israel, that in Poland babies sock anti-Semitism with their mother’s milk. However, he mentions that traditionally the Jews attached a great value to their Jewish identity and did so at high cost of causing suspicion of their conspiratorial behavior. This was very much the case when Soviet Army invaded Poland and recruited disproportional amount of Jews to serve in the Soviet terror apparatus and the Communist Party. Thus, unjustly many victims of Soviet oppression created a stereotype that “every Jew in Poland is a communist.”
Unfortunately, there are symmetrical prejudices, which were cultivated among Polish Jews against Poles and Catholics. Professor Chrostowski was aware of very many examples of this phenomenon while working for years as the co-president of the Council of Christians and Jews in Poland and as a member the Commission of the Episcopate of Poland for the Dialog with Judaism. The obstacles experienced in this dialog, after several years, caused the resignation of professor Chrostowski of his functions in both of these programs. He gave a very credible version of events related to the eviction of the Monastery of the Carmelite Order from the vicinity of Auschwitz. His version was very different from the common version of Tygodnik Powszechny and Communist controlled Television.
Professor Chrostowski noticed that in Poland in Auschwitz, Rabin Wiess could behave in such a provocative manner that would cause his arrest in any western country, but not in Communist Poland, where the government thrived on exploitation of religious and ethnic antagonisms in a country in which communists experienced many ideological difficulties.
Already in 1920 during the battle for Lwów, Stalin wrote a memorable plan for creation of Soviet Empire composed of Soviet republics and of subjugated satellite states. Stalin wrote that he believed that it would be easier to put a saddle on a cow than to install communism in Poland.
In an earlier article on “Calming the winds of war” I have cited Isaac Bashevis Singer (1904-1991), a winner of the Nobel Prize in literature, who recognized a longstanding separation between Jews and Poles in Poland. Singer wrote an article titled "Jews and Poles Lived Together for 800 Years But Were Not Integrated." The article appeared in the New York-based Jewish newspaper Forverts on Sept. 17, 1944 under the pen name Iccok Warszawski. He wrote: "Rarely did a Jew think it necessary to learn Polish; rarely was a Jew interested in Polish history or Polish politics." Referring to the Second Polish Republic (1918-1939) he continued "Even in the last few years it was still a rare occurrence that a Jew would speak Polish well. Out of three million Jews living in Poland, two-and-a-half million were not able to write a simple letter in Polish and they spoke [Polish] very poorly. There were hundreds of thousands of Jews in Poland to whom Polish was as unfamiliar as Turkish."
Singer later wrote in Forverts, March 20, 1964 "My mouth could not get accustomed to the soft consonants of [Polish] language. My forefathers have lived for centuries in Poland but in reality I was a foreigner, with separate language, ideas and religion. I sensed the oddness of this situation and often considered moving to Palestine." (The above quotations are from Chone Shmeruk's Isaac Bashevis Singer and Bruno Schultz published in the Polish Review. Vol. XXXVI, No. 2, 1991: 161-
Thus coming back to the after dinner conversation in which one of the ladies asked her family friend: “Are you an anti-Semite?” she was properly asked: “How do you define an anti-Semite?” Then it was recalled that professor of theology at the University of Cardinal Wyszyński in Warsaw, Monsignior Waldemar Chrostowski, convincingly defined an anti-Semite as “a person disliked by some Jew.”
WWW.pogonowski.com
|
28 grudzień 2011
|
Iwo Cyprian Pogonowski
|
|
|
|
Niebo
sierpień 20, 2003
Andrzej Kumor
|
"ONI"
luty 1, 2003
Jerzy Przystawa
|
numerus clausus i numerus nullus
lipiec 10, 2008
Piotr Hßbner
|
Problem ze zrozumieniem tekstu czytanego
grudzień 3, 2007
Artur Łoboda
|
Do końca
wrzesień 17, 2003
Andrzej Kumor
|
Czasem się coś w Gazecie Wyborczej trafi, ale znika szybko...
styczeń 12, 2004
czytelnik
|
Prezydent Wenezueli, Hugo Chávez Frías, 20 wrzesnia 2006, na forum Zgromadzenia Ogólnego ONZ
wrzesień 23, 2006
Tlum. Roman K.
|
Sprzedaż relikwii religii Holokaustu zakazana: eBay wycofał naszywkę z II Wojny Światowej
listopad 9, 2007
bibula
|
300 zł za muzykę na prywatce
grudzień 29, 2005
|
Solidarność 25 lat w Instytucie
maj 28, 2005
Jerzy Kowalewski
|
MSZ będzie zabiegać o wsparcie Polonii dla integracji
grudzień 20, 2002
Adam Zieliński
|
Dla Premiera trawniki ważniejsze od ludzi...
sierpień 28, 2003
Mirosław Żeberek
|
Czy Rosja jest supermocarstwem?
marzec 17, 2008
tłumacz
|
Ogryzek leży w kałuży
lipiec 16, 2008
ZYGMUNT JAN PRUSIŃSKI
|
Dzisiaj mam urlop
lipiec 27, 2008
Marek Jastrząb
|
Imperium na kredyt
luty 11, 2006
Iwo Cyprian Pogonowski
|
Oświadczenie Stronnictwa Narodowego Okręgu Opolskiego
wrzesień 1, 2004
Bolesław Grabowski
|
Pakistan traktowany jak republika bananowa w celu pacyfikacji Afganistanu
wrzesień 15, 2007
Iwo Cyprian Pogonowski
|
Nie oglądajcie się
marzec 13, 2003
zaprasza.net
|
niestrudzeni - z kart historii
luty 21, 2003
Ż Ś Mirosław M. Krupinski
|
|
|